Politico issued a correction after critics called out media outlets for erroneously attributing a theory about the COVID vaccine to Justice Clarence Thomas.
On Thursday, the Supreme Court announced that it would not hear a case challenging New York’s vaccine mandate. In 2021, a group of anonymous healthcare workers filed a lawsuit against the state claiming that taking the vaccine would violate their religious beliefs.
Thomas, along with Justices Neil Gorsuch and Samuel Alito, released a dissenting opinion criticizing the decision for ignoring religious exemptions.
Thomas included a description of the healthcare workers’ belief that some COVID vaccines were developed using aborted fetal cells.
“Petitioners are 16 healthcare workers who served New York communities throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. They object on religious grounds to all available COVID–19 vaccines because they were developed using cell lines derived from aborted children,” Thomas wrote.
However, among other outlets, Politico falsely attributed the theory to Thomas rather than the healthcare workers, running the headline, “Clarence Thomas suggests Covid vaccines are developed using cells of ‘aborted children.’”
“Clarence Thomas claimed in a dissenting opinion that Covid vaccines are derived from the cells of ‘aborted children,’” Politico wrote in the now-deleted tweet. “No Covid vaccines in the U.S. contain the cells of aborted fetuses.”
On Friday, Politico issued a correction reading, “An earlier version of this report misattributed the claim that Covid-19 vaccines were ‘developed using cell lines derived from aborted children’ to Thomas. The headline and article have been updated to directly state that Thomas was referencing petitioners’ claims.”
The headline was also changed to, “Clarence Thomas cites claim that Covid vaccines are ‘developed using cell lines derived from aborted children.'”
In addition to Politico, outlets like Axios and NBC News similarly portrayed Thomas as being a promoter of the theory.
Axios ran the headline, “Clarence Thomas suggests COVID vaccines are created with cells from ‘aborted children.’” However, an earlier version of the headline read, “Clarence Thomas suggests COVID vaccines are made with ‘aborted children.'” An editor’s note at the bottom of the article said, “The headline and lead of this story have been updated to note Thomas was referencing cells of ‘aborted children’ in his dissent.”
The report from Axios does acknowledge, however, that some vaccines do use fetal cells in research.
Meanwhile, MSNBC and NBC News insisted that the claim was “discredited,” with MSNBC’s Steve Benen adding that Thomas’ statement further “tarnishes” the court.
“The Supreme Court’s credibility was already suffering. The more justices publish factual errors, the more it further tarnishes the court’s reputation,” Benen wrote in a piece titled, “Clarence Thomas cites discredited claim about Covid vaccines.”
NBC’s headline read, “Justice Thomas cites debunked claim that Covid vaccines are made with cells from ‘aborted children,'” and even wrote that “Justice Clarence Thomas expressed support Thursday for a debunked claim that all Covid vaccines are made with cells from ‘aborted children,’” before later admitting Thomas was “citing the plaintiffs.”
This is an excerpt from Fox News.
Scroll down to leave a comment and share your thoughts.